Analyst Comment

“Zero Emission Vehicle” – the biggest automotive fib?

Credit: Bert van Dijk/Getty images.

Powered by

While waiting in traffic behind a brand-new battery electric vehicle (BEV) recently, I couldn’t help but notice the shiny badge stating, “Zero Emission.” But is there such a thing? Was the process of creating that badge even net zero emission? – probably not. But I’d like to explore the current state of play when talking about vehicular emissions and the prospect of ‘zero’ emissions. 

First and foremost, BEVs and hydrogen fuel cell vehicles can accurately be described as zero tailpipe emission vehicles. BEVs do not have tailpipes and hydrogen cell fuel vehicles release only water vapour as a by-product of their propulsion system, but other emissions are released beyond those purely resulting from the operation of the powertrain.

Production

Firstly, the manufacture of all vehicles results in emissions. For example, material mining, processing, machining, treating, and assembly, all require energy and generate chemical byproducts released as hydrocarbons and carbon emissions. Unfortunately, it is almost impossible to truly produce anything non-organic that is emission-free, without perhaps a hermetically sealed factory. Some facilities offer net zero production by offsetting their emissions against a saving elsewhere, but all production causes direct emissions of some description. Battery electric vehicles typically require the processing of more material than ICE vehicles, causing greater production emissions, due to the addition of a large traction battery.

Transportation

Getting the vehicle to the customer, unless the vehicle happens to be produced in a factory close by, involves the vehicle being transported. In many cases, the vehicle is already on the right continent, and may only need to be transported on the back of an emissions-producing truck. But it may very well, need to be shipped long distance from overseas – how, you ask? By a fossil fuel consuming, toxic gas and particulate emitting car carrier vessel.

Energy production

At present, the electrical energy used to power the zero-emission vehicles, whilst having the potential to be generated from renewable sources, may very well not be. For example, in the UK in 2023, a third of electrical energy was generated using fossil fuels (the remainder split 12% nuclear and 55% renewables, including significant bioenergy, which may not be truly renewable). So, there is no guarantee today that the ‘zero emission’ car in front of me was operating zero-emission electricity.

Brake emissions

Battery electric vehicles or hybrid electric vehicles do release considerably fewer brake emissions than internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles due to regenerative braking. However, all vehicles still have friction brakes, and all vehicles do use those brakes and hence will release particulate emissions in the form of brake dust. For example, any electric vehicle that is fully charged (charged to 100%) does not have regenerative braking capability and will rely entirely on friction brakes. Hence, a BEV charged to 100% and controlling its descent from the top of a hill versus an equivalent ICE vehicle doing the same will release more brake emissions as both will be relying on friction brakes, but the BEV is likely to be heavier.

Tyre emissions

Tyres always have and frankly always will produce particulates, as does any friction-dependent device. Only in recent years has the environmental harm of the microplastics, chemicals and heavy metals hidden in vehicle tyres begun to come to light. Some tyre companies are exploring ways to reduce their emissions by implementing harder composites, and others are exploring electrostatic devices that can ‘suck up’ these emissions.

Refrigerant

All vehicles with air conditioning, battery cooling or heat pumps will utilise a type of refrigerant that may harm the environment. As a result, in recent years some automotive companies have announced a switch to less environmentally damaging refrigerants. In a perfect world, refrigerant would not be a concern as the exact quantity of refrigerant injected into the vehicle systems at the production stage would be removed at the vehicle’s end of life with no loss. However, in reality, it escapes. It escapes through seals, during the filling process, where it voids to the atmosphere, through the service process, which is required when enough refrigerant has leaked out of the system, or when any front-end collision causes a rupture to a condenser or any other refrigerant-carrying device. And what makes this so concerning is that refrigerant is up to two thousand times more harmful (gram for gram) than carbon dioxide when contributing to the greenhouse effect. 

In summary, there is no such thing as a zero-emission vehicle at present. However, zero tailpipe emission vehicles and even hybridised vehicles will play a pivotal role in the pursuit of zero emissions and are essential in reducing overall emissions from the automotive industry and protecting our environment.

This article was first published on GlobalData’s dedicated research platform, the Automotive Intelligence Center. For more details on GlobalData’s designated Global Light Vehicle Powertrain module, click here.

GlobalData, the leading provider of industry intelligence, provided the underlying data, research, and analysis;used to produce this article.

GlobalData’s Thematic Intelligence uses proprietary data, research, and analysis to provide a forward-looking perspective on the key themes that will shape the future of the world’s largest industries and the organisations within them.

Go to article: Home | Get ready for ESG 2.0Go to article: ContentsGo to article: BriefingGo to article: Foreword: A growing sense of urgency in ESG Go to article: ESG 1.0 is over – get ready for ESG 2.0 Go to article: ESG becomes mandatory: how to prepareGo to article: Theme timeline: the past, present and future of ESG Go to article: GlobalData’s Christopher Papadopoullos on net-zero strategy for businesses Go to article: 38% of companies lack an ESG strategy – GlobalData survey Go to article: Why sustainability reporting standards must be simple, consistent and transparentGo to article: HealthcareGo to article: Net-zero strategies for the pharma sector Go to article: Leading pharma companies and initiatives in the race for net zeroGo to article: Case study: Medtronic MiniMed extended infusion set a step forward for sustainability Go to article: Latest news: ESG in healthcareGo to article: Sustainability challenges in rare disease trials remain, but change is happeningGo to article: ESCMID 2024: The infectious consequences of climate change Go to article: Can pharma overcome generative AI’s bias problem?Go to article: China-US tensions are spilling into the biotech sector Go to article: World Air Quality Report: what are the health impacts and where is it worst? Go to article: Deal activity related to ESG in the pharma industry since 2021Go to article: Bring your own device: How patients own tech is being used in clinical trialsGo to article: Another recall: does Philips have a quality control problem? Go to article: FemTech: the world’s largest ‘niche’ market Go to article: Are therapists safe from AI disruption? Go to article: Japanese patients among least empowered in the developed worldGo to article: Why has New Zealand U-turned on the world’s first smoking ban?Go to article: Deal activity related to ESG in the medical device industry since 2021  Go to article: Sponsorship opportunitiesGo to article: PowerGo to article: Net-zero strategies for the power sector Go to article: Leading power companies in the race for net zeroGo to article: Latest news: ESG in power Go to article: ‘Sheer scale of the challenge’ the biggest barrier to net zero in APAC Go to article: How can AI help us adapt to an evolving climate? Go to article: How “energy-hungry AI” is straining grids Go to article: Innovation in green hydrogen driving surge in investment Go to article: Can natural hydrogen play a role in net zero? Go to article: Wind turbines are ageing – what happens next? Go to article: What are sustainability-linked loans and why are they struggling? Go to article: Deal activity related to ESG in the power industry since 2021Go to article: Oil & GasGo to article: Net-zero strategies for the oil & gas sector Go to article: Latest news: ESG in oil & gas Go to article: New report accuses fossil fuel companies of greenwashing, but profits are up Go to article: MethaneSat will remind the oil and gas sector “to get back to work”Go to article: How will MethaneSat help to reduce methane emissions? Go to article: How realistic is a global fossil fuels tax to aid the green transition? Go to article: “Britain has become more unequal”: Greenpeace on green transition tax Go to article: Deal activity related to ESG in the oil and gas industry since 2021  Go to article: MiningGo to article: Net-zero strategies for the mining sector Go to article: Leading mining companies in the race for net zeroGo to article: Latest news: ESG in miningGo to article: GlobalData’s Thomas Pothalingam on the critical battery industryGo to article: Pentagon looks to AI to predict prices of critical minerals for weaponsGo to article: McKinsey’s Roland Rechtsteiner on the energy transition and commodities marketsGo to article: Deal activity related to ESG in the mining industry since 2021Go to article: GlobalData Thematic IntelligenceGo to article: DefenceGo to article: Net-zero strategies for the defence sectorGo to article: Leading defence companies in the race for net zero Go to article: Latest news: ESG in defenceGo to article: Toxic artillery: Paradigm Shift Technologies on chrome plating Go to article: How is Russia weaponising ‘ecocide’ in Ukraine? Go to article: Environmental damage rampant across Ukraine and Gaza – CEOBS Go to article: What would orbiting nuclear weapons mean for the space economy? Go to article: Ethical constraints the biggest challenge for AI in defence Go to article: OpenAI faces protests for military applications, but the market is growing Go to article: How ‘AI killer robots’ are threatening global securityGo to article: Deal activity related to ESG in the aerospace & defence industry since 2021  Go to article: AutoGo to article: Net-zero strategies for the automotive sectorGo to article: Leading auto companies in the race for net zeroGo to article: ESG News in the Automotive sectorGo to article: GKN Automotive: Sustainability “is constantly evolving”Go to article: “Zero Emission Vehicle” – the biggest automotive fib?Go to article: How China’s EV battery tech is cementing it as the auto industry leaderGo to article: Carmakers face allegations of Uyghur forced labour in ChinaGo to article: Deal activity related to ESG in the automotive industry since 2021Go to article: ApparelGo to article: Net-zero strategies for the apparel and retail sector Go to article: Sustainability solutions for apparel companies Go to article: Latest News: ESG in apparelGo to article: Are fashion brands on track with ESG goals? Go to article: WRAP SVP: EU’s ESG leadership sets tone for US fashion brands Go to article: Fashion’s polluting title debunked but tackling toxic impact remains vital Go to article: The greenwashing crackdown and how fashion brands can ensure compliance Go to article: Gen Z’s fraught relationship with ESG-friendly missions Go to article: Social media ‘coolness’ trumps sustainability for retail consumers Go to article: Are mushrooms the future of leather? Go to article: Deal activity related to ESG in the apparel industry since 2021Go to article: ConsumerGo to article: Net-zero strategies for the consumer goods sectorGo to article: Case study: Kraft Heinz green hydrogen plantGo to article: Latest news: ESG in foodGo to article: Is Unilever’s bold ESG plan enough to hit net zero? Go to article: The problems with ‘carbon negative’ claimsGo to article: Why claims of ‘sustainable’ beef should be taken with a pinch of saltGo to article: Cocoa prices continue to rise. When might the tide turn? Go to article: EU pesticide bans: what are the impacts and are they necessary? Go to article: Why are UK infant formula prices rising – and what will the CMA do about it?Go to article: Deal activity related to ESG in the food industry since 2021Go to article: Latest news: ESG in drinksGo to article: Preparing for the “second wave” Go to article: Can genetic breeding ease brewers’ climate concerns?Go to article: Deal activity related to ESG in the beverages industry since 2021Go to article: PackagingGo to article: Consumer goods companies focus on sustainable packaging Go to article: Latest news: ESG in packaging Go to article: The current state of ESG in the packaging industry Go to article: Judging a book by its cover Go to article: Key players shaping sustainable packaging trends Go to article: Interview Enhancing ESG through innovative food packaging solutions Go to article: Eco-packaging solutions for perishable goods in transit Go to article: Why manufacturers need to take the circular economy seriously Go to article: Microplastics in placentas: how serious is the problem? Go to article: Global trend of plain tobacco packaging gains momentum Go to article: Deal activity related to ESG in the packaging industry since 2021  Go to article: BankingGo to article: Net-zero strategies for the financial services sector Go to article: Leading financial services companies in the race for net zero Go to article: Latest news: ESG in banking Go to article: Sustainable investing in a tech-driven future Go to article: “ESG is good business” – UNEP FI’s Eric Usher Go to article: Financial services firms must focus on Scope 3 to achieve net zero Go to article: Why the payment industry needs to “go bespoke” to deliver true financial inclusiGo to article: How will the EU’s AI act impact financial services? Go to article: What is digital cash and why are there privacy concerns around it? Go to article: Social media continues to disrupt the banking industry Go to article: Deal activity related to ESG in the retail banking industry since 2021Go to article: Next issue